One deduction is painful. Two for the same issue? That’s a margin leak with a trench coat on. Duplicate deductions usually aren’t malicious. They’re procedural. Multiple systems, multiple teams, and multiple “reasons” can get attached to the same underlying event—especially when disputes are rushed, and documentation is scattered.

February can feel… quieter. No holiday promo chaos. No year-end close panic. Just a brief window where you can finally look up. And that’s exactly when a lot of suppliers discover the problem: deductions have been stacking up in the background, hiding in offsets, short pays, and messy remittance detail. One industry paper from the Return Value Chain Federation (RVCF) put it bluntly: depending on the industry, customer deductions can reach 5%–15% of revenue, and even “typical”

Tariffs don’t just change costs. They change deductions. Because the moment your costs move, you’re in a race between reality and the retailer’s system.

Last year, you could win a dispute with a decent note and a screenshot. This year, that same package gets denied because it’s missing the lot code, the timestamp, the condition photo, and the proof of delivery. It feels personal. It’s not.

January is when retailers try to get their house back in order. They’ve got seasonal inventory to clear, new sets to build, and demand that usually cools off after December. One study found retail spending drops an average 22.4% between December and January.

Learn how to tackle defective deductions in Q1 returns. Stop losing money to defective deductions with our expert guidance and boost your margins.

Discover the 2026 Grocery Deduction Hotspots! Learn how shortages and unsaleables impact profits and how to tackle grocery deduction challenges.