Cyber Monday: E-Commerce Deductions to Expect

Cyber Monday is a rocket booster for sales—and a magnet for deductions. When orders surge, small disconnects in marketplace fee math, split shipments, or “porch piracy” claims can snowball into accounts payable (AP) headaches and post-audit chargebacks.

What’s at stake: margins you thought you earned. Ignore these issues, and January remittance surprises can erase the win you just worked for.

Fictional example (for illustration): A wellness brand saw record Cyber Monday orders. But a promotion auto-split multi-item orders into two shipments. The second parcel arrived a day later, creating partial-delivery complaints and “item not received” (often called porch piracy) claims. Marketplace fees were also calculated on the pre-discount price plus shipping, not what finance accrued. Result: dozens of small deductions that added up to a real hit.

The e-commerce deduction hotspots

1. Split shipments

   • Why it happens: Inventory allocated across nodes or ship-complete settings disabled.

   • Risk: Partial deliveries trigger “not received” or late claims, and refunds don’t always tie back cleanly to the original order.

   • Fix: For high-velocity SKUs (stock keeping units), prefer ship-complete on promotional bundles; if you must split, auto-attach both tracking numbers to one order record and one proof of delivery (POD).

2. Porch claims (aka “item not received”)

   • Why it happens: Carrier shows “delivered,” customer says “no package.”

   • Risk: Fast refunds get taken as deductions; appeals fail without evidence.

   • Fix: Enable delivery photo where available; require carrier geo-coordinates on delivery scans; route high-value orders to “signature required” during Cyber Week.

3. Marketplace fee math

   • Why it happens: Fees are often calculated on item price, sometimes including shipping, gift wrap, or taxes depending on marketplace rules.

   • Risk: Finance accrues one way; the marketplace bills another → fee variances and billbacks.

   • Fix: Maintain a fee matrix by marketplace and listing type; reconcile daily for the top 20 SKUs.

4. Return window + refund timing

   • Why it happens: Extended holiday return policies shift when refunds hit.

   • Risk: Refund-related deductions arrive months later; proofs are stale.

   • Fix: Auto-store return merchandise authorization (RMA) numbers, photos, and reason codes alongside the order ID.

A Cyber Monday playbook that actually works

• Order orchestration:

  • Use ship-complete for bundles; otherwise, attach all tracking numbers to one event in your order management system (OMS).

  • Flag split shipments in a “watch” queue for delivery variance follow-up.

• Delivery evidence:

  • Turn on photo on delivery and signature required thresholds (e.g., orders >$150).

  • Store carrier scans, geolocation, and photos by order ID for 120 days.

• Fee reconciliation:

  • Daily export of marketplace settlement vs. finance accruals.

  • Exception report for orders with promos, free shipping, or gift wrap.

• Return hygiene:

  • Require RMA + photos for all returns; auto-classify reason codes (damage, defective, remorse).

  • Tie refunds to the original tender and keep timestamps (order → ship → deliver → refund).

Cyber Monday checklist (copy/paste)

• Ship-complete enabled for promo bundles

• All split shipments tied to single POD record

• Delivery photo + signature thresholds live

• Marketplace fee matrix validated (by listing type)

• Daily fee exception report running by noon

• RMA + photo capture on every return

Too much “Cyber Monday exposure”? HRG can help. Let's talk.

Contact Us