Promotional Allowances: When Trade Spend Springs a Leak

Promotional allowances are supposed to be the controlled part of the retailer relationship.

You plan the event.You fund the discount. You track the lift.

And then… two months later… deductions show up that don’t match anything anyone remembers approving.

That’s the moment trade spend stops feeling like growth investment and starts feeling like a slow leak.

Here’s the big, uncomfortable truth: CPG companies invest about 20% of revenue annually in trade Promotions, and research cited by McKinsey notes 59% of Promotions lose money globally—72% in the U.S.

So even before deductions misfire, the Promotional engine is already under strain.

And when Promotional allowances are messy, the strain becomes a cash flow problem.

What counts as a promotional allowance (in normal human language)

Promotional allowances show up in different costumes:

• Off-invoice discounts

• Bill-backs / post-audit bill-backs

• Scan-downs and scan-backs

• Lump-sum events

• Accrual-based funding

• Growth incentives tied to thresholds

The mechanics vary, but the failure mode is consistent:

Sales and marketing remember the Promotional. AP remembers the deduction. The retailer remembers whatever the system recorded.

Those three memories do not always match.

A fictional scenario that happens every day

Your brand runs a clean two-week Promotional in a defined region.

Sales has the agreement. Marketing has the ad screenshots. The retailer has the event ID… sort of.

Then deductions hit against:

• SKUs that weren’t on the deal

• Stores that weren’t in the region

• Dates outside the window

• A rate that’s 2 points deeper than the signed terms

Nobody’s lying.

But the system is drifting.

The 4 drifts that turn Promotional dollars into deduction chaos

1) Terms drift A revised agreement lives in an inbox. The retailer portal reflects the old one. Deductions follow the portal.

2) Eligibility drift Item lists, pack sizes, and substitutions shift. One SKU change can derail the mapping and pull deductions against the wrong items.

3) Proof drift You have proof of performance, but it’s not connected to the deduction in a way the retailer’s process will accept.

4) Timing drift Promotions settle on timelines that don’t align with your internal close calendar. By the time finance asks, the supporting docs are buried.

The “Dispute-Ready Promotional” framework

If promotions are a top P&L line, they deserve a structure that can survive contact with deductions.

Here’s the framework we recommend:

Step 1: Write a one-page Promotional brief for every event Not a deck. Not a thread. A single page that includes:

• Retailer + banner/region/store list

• Event dates (start/stop)

• Eligible SKUs and pack sizes

• Funding method (off-invoice, bill-back, scan, accrual)

• Rate or dollars + caps (very important)

• Required proof (ads, features, displays, screenshots, POS)

• Primary internal owner + backup

Step 2: Assign a unique internal event ID that matches the retailer reference If you can’t tie the deduction to the event in seconds, you’re already behind.

Step 3: Create a shared “Promotional evidence folder” before the Promotional starts Don’t wait until deductions arrive. Make it easy for the future-you.

Step 4: Run three reconciliations

• Day 1: confirm price/terms loaded correctly

• Mid-Promotional: verify execution (not just plan)

• 30–60 days post: reconcile deductions to terms while documentation is still fresh

Step 5: Build a Promotional exception queue Not everything is worth disputing. But exceptions should be triaged fast:

• Out-of-window

• Wrong SKU

• Wrong geography

• Wrong rate

• Duplicate deductions

The quiet benefit: better retailer conversations

This isn’t just about recovery.

When your team can say, calmly and factually: “Here’s the signed term, here’s the store list, here’s the event window, here’s the proof, here’s where the deduction deviates,” …you stop having emotional disputes.

You start having operational corrections.

That’s a healthier partnership for everyone.

Where HRG fits

Most internal teams can plan promotions. That’s not the issue.

The issue is that promotions create high-volume, high-complexity deductions—and if your process isn’t built to validate quickly, “we’ll look at it later” becomes a permanent revenue haircut.

HRG helps suppliers put structure around promotion deductions so you can:

• recover what doesn’t match terms,

• clean up repeat errors,

and make trade spend feel like an investment again—not a mystery bill.

Contact Us