top of page

How to Prioritize Deduction Recovery: A Five-Factor Scorecard

Writer: Jon Allen
Jon Allen
Oct 15
2 min read

Updated: Oct 31

Piggy bank hidden in tall grass

Which Deductions Deserve Your Attention First?

When deduction volume is high, investigating every claim in the order received isn't always the most effective use of resources. HRG helps suppliers find, investigate, and recover unsupported retail deductions. When claim volume is high, deduction recovery works best when you start with the claims that matter most. This scorecard, from HRG's Supplier Intelligence Toolkit, scores each claim on five factors so you can prioritize deduction recovery with a clear method.

Use this five-factor scorecard to prioritize potential recovery opportunities.

Prioritization Factor

Score

Financial Impact: How much recoverable revenue may be at stake?

1-5

Frequency: Is the same issue occurring repeatedly?

1-5

Supporting Evidence: How complete is the documentation supporting a dispute?

1-5

Recovery Feasibility: How strong is the basis for a valid, timely recovery claim?

1-5

Future Prevention: Could addressing the issue reduce additional deductions?

1-5

Total Potential Score

5-25

How to interpret the score:

  • 20–25: High-priority investigation

  • 13–19: Review and evaluate

  • 5–12: Monitor or investigate as resources permit


Your Intelligence Question:

Are we allocating our recovery resources to the opportunities with the greatest potential value?


Practical next step: Score your 20 largest unresolved deduction issues. Compare financial impact with supporting documentation, and recovery feasibility to establish investigation priorities.


Important: This is an initial prioritization aid, not a validated prediction of recovery. Claims approaching retailer dispute deadlines should be escalated regardless of their score.

Why it pays to prioritize deduction recovery: HRG is a retail deduction recovery firm in Bentonville, Arkansas. Since 2010, HRG has helped suppliers find, investigate, and recover more than $1 billion in retail deductions and claims. Claims differ in dollar value, evidence, and dispute deadlines, so no team can work them all at once. To prioritize deduction recovery, score your open claims first. Then spend your time on the ones with strong evidence and real money at stake. The scorecard above is a starting point. It is not a prediction of what you will recover. If you want a second set of eyes on your highest scores, request a free review of your deduction history.

The intelligence is already in the data.


HRG IQ is here. Turn Insight into Action.

Questions About Prioritizing Deduction Recovery

How do I decide which deductions to work first? Score each claim from 1 to 5 on financial impact, frequency, supporting evidence, recovery feasibility, and future prevention. The total runs from 5 to 25. A score of 20 to 25 is high priority, 13 to 19 needs review, and 5 to 12 can be monitored or investigated as resources allow.

Where should I start? Score your 20 largest unresolved deduction issues. Compare financial impact with your documentation and with how strong the basis is for a valid, timely claim.

Does a high score mean I will recover the money? No. The scorecard is an initial aid, not a validated prediction of recovery. Claims close to a retailer's dispute deadline should be escalated whatever their score.


HRG is a retail deduction recovery firm in Bentonville, Arkansas. Since 2010, we have helped suppliers find, investigate and recover more than $1 billion in retail deductions and claims. Request a free review of your deduction history.

Jon Allen is Chief Marketing Officer at HRG. He has a Walmart Home Office background.

bottom of page